Insurance
Can an Insurer Drop You Over Your Roof's Age?
Why roof age drives Florida insurance decisions, and what to do if you get a notice.
Limited time offer 4 point home inspection or wind mitigation with any new roof See what is includedAn insurer can decline to renew a Florida policy over roof age, and many now underwrite on it directly. Age is not the same as condition, though: a roof in good shape with documentation behind it is a different conversation. If a non-renewal notice arrives, act on it rather than waiting.
Roof age has become one of the main things Florida insurers underwrite on, and homeowners here get non-renewal notices that mention it. This explains why that happens and what your options are. It is general information, not advice about your policy — your agent and your policy documents are the authority on your situation.
Why age specifically
An insurer is pricing the chance of paying for a roof in the next few years. Age is the simplest predictor they have, and it needs no inspection. Condition matters more than age in reality, but age is what fits on a form.
Age is not the same as condition
A well-installed roof that has been maintained can be in better shape than a younger one that was done badly or has been through a storm. The difference is real, and demonstrating it takes documentation — an inspection report, permit history, evidence of repairs done properly.
Florida homeowners are not without protection
Florida has passed measures intended to stop insurers refusing coverage on roof age alone where a roof still has serviceable life, generally by allowing an inspection to establish that. The specifics have changed more than once in recent years, so ask your agent what applies to your policy now rather than relying on what was true a couple of years ago.
What to do when a notice arrives
Read what it actually says — non-renewal, cancellation and a conditional renewal are different things with different deadlines. Then get an inspection of the roof, so the conversation is about your specific roof rather than its birthday. Shop the policy in parallel; carriers differ substantially on this.
Repair, replace, or document
There are three honest answers and only you can weigh them. Document, if the roof is genuinely sound and the paperwork will show it. Repair, if the problem is specific. Replace, if it is at the end of its life — in which case a new roof usually improves what you pay, which offsets part of the cost.
What we will not tell you
We will not tell you what your insurer will accept, or that a new roof guarantees a particular premium. We can tell you what condition your roof is in and what it would take to put it right. Your agent owns the rest.
If you have had a notice mentioning your roof, call 239-414-9100. Knowing what condition it is really in is the first step, and looking costs you nothing.
Want this looked at on your own home?
Let our experts look over your property—no cost, no obligation.